« 'Fairly Definitive Proof of Media Bias' |
Main
| Reality Check »
Journos Admit Hamas Fired From Media Buildings
Via IsraelMatzav, journalist Paula Slier visited Gaza for the first time since Operation Cast Lead. She came away with a particularly startling admission from fellow reporters who were in the strip during the war:
Colleagues in our sister organisation, Russia Al Yaum, said Hamas fighters had been hiding in the basement of the media building and they couldn't go on air and admit it as otherwise they would have become targets. So, in this respect at least, when the Israeli army justified its attacks on media houses, they were telling the truth when they said fire was coming from them!
This confirms a point I recently argued in defense of Israel's wartime press restrictions. Many journalists were not "neutral observers," but "participants" (sometimes willing participants, sometimes not).
If you haven't seen it already, here's a video of an Al-Arabiya reporter discovering that a rocket was fired from her own media building.
By the way, the Gaza war was the primary reason Reporters Without Borders (better known as RSF) dropped Israel 47 places from last year in its annual Press Freedom Index. Not that the RSF's high-profile ranking would dare to call Hamas onto the carpet for endangering reporters . . .
Posted at
08:49 AM
TrackBack URL for this entry: http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d834515b7869e2012876fc971e970c
Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Journos Admit Hamas Fired From Media Buildings:
I don't suppose there's any value in passing on this information to Sir Richard Goldstone, is there?
Of course, that's right. He'll ignore it like he did with similar evidence when he was er ... oops I mean making his report.
Posted by: Anna at Jan 23, 2010 2:09:01 PM
At last the "liberal" antisemitic concensus is crumbling!
Posted by: Frugal Dougal at Jan 23, 2010 8:13:21 PM
A British blogger has been intimidated by the police. The Reverend Stephen Sizer didn’t like comments and criticism made on the Seismic Shock blog, so got the police to physically intimidate the blogger, to take down that mild criticism.
This is a clear freedom of speech issue, the police should not be used to intimidate bloggers.
I urge you to publicise this issue and support Seismic Shock, as “I too am Seismic Shock”
For more information see http://modernityblog.wordpress.com/2010/01/23/reverend-stephen-sizer-uses-british-police-against-a-blogger/
And http://engageonline.wordpress.com/2010/01/23/anglican-vicar-uses-police-to-intimidate-blogger/
Posted by: modernity at Jan 23, 2010 11:39:45 PM
Proportionality in Modern
Asymmetrical Wars by Amichai Cohen
As the uses of force in Somalia, Kosovo and Iraq show, Western armies are very concerned about protecting the lives of their soldiers, and to that end are willing to risk many civilian lives. They also find acceptable the notion that civilian lives can be forfeited in order to attain important military goals. Israel’s Gaza operation clearly shows that Israeli commanders successfully followed the requirements of the administrative model of the principle of proportionality. The IDF required commanders to take humanitarian law into account in the planning stages of the operation. Legal advisors were involved in the planning of many operations and provided advice regarding specific targets. The right questions were asked, checks were made, and the incidental damage to civilians was on the whole limited. For the entire article please go to: http://www.jcpa.org/text/proportionality.pdf
Posted by: debka at Jan 24, 2010 3:13:14 PM
Please tell me how I can get the IBA news on my PC like I used to have years ago when I had Direct TV. Where I live Direct is not available. Shalom!
Posted by: Mitch at Feb 3, 2010 2:05:51 AM
|