« CMAJ Editor-in-Chief Responds |
Main
| Great Moments in Israeli Clock Changes »
Daily Telegraph's Twisted Headline
The IDF released updated casualty stats from the January Gaza war. According to Haaretz, the army lists 1,370 fatalities overall, which include:
- More than 600 members of terror organizations.
- 309 confirmed civilians, of which 189 were children under the age of 15.
- 320 people whose status as civilian or fighter has not yet been confirmed.
This prompted a very twisted headline in the Daily Telegraph:

In reality, 189, while tragic, is a very small number when you consider that a large percentage of Gaza's estimated population of 1.4 million are children.
Had the IDF had indeed attacked civilians targets indiscriminately in the densely populated strip, the stats would show a sharply higher percentage of kids among the overall casualties.
But the majority of casualties are among men of fighting age, suggesting that even when accidents happened, the IDF was actually deliberately targeting its fire rather than indiscriminately blasting away.
Posted at
12:49 PM
TrackBack URL for this entry: http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d834515b7869e201156e632c94970c
Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Daily Telegraph's Twisted Headline:
This Daily Telegraph article, though too short and not detailed enough in my opinion,is one of the few in national press to deal with the latest war crime libels in a fair and balanced way - despite the "twisted headline".
Since this latest orgy of Israel-bashing was largely started by Israeli leftist post-/anti-Zionists, within and outside the media, you would do better to put together a long and detailed study of Haaretz - most of whose journalists dealing with the conflict write about it in a thoroughly dishonest way - instead of getting unduly worked up by misleading headlines.
P.S. The latest article by Isi Leibler, posted today on http://wordfromjerusalem.com/?p=1586 is absolutely required reading - "Jewish Blood Libels".
It is time for Haaretz and hypocritical defamers of the IDF like Zamir to be restrained by the fear of regular libel actions.
Someone like the respected lawyer Trevor Asserson should be asked to get involved in an initiative of this nature.
Posted by: Paul at Mar 26, 2009 1:23:21 PM
I get the Telegrph every day, although I missed that article. I'm surprised and disappointed, it's usually a more responsible paper, with a healthy respect for the truth and for Israel's situation.
I wonder if the Palestinians were using child soldiers?
Posted by: Frugal Dougal at Mar 26, 2009 2:06:30 PM
I'm certain those children were human shields for hamas.
The media, in particular the British media, are enemies of civilization.
Posted by: Laura at Mar 26, 2009 6:17:02 PM
|