 |
|
|
Wednesday, February 25 2009British Medical Journal Attacks HonestReportingThe BMJ falsely accuses HonestReporting of attempting to stifle debate and freedom of speech. Read more at HonestReporting's latest communique: British Medical Journal Attacks HonestReporting
TrackBackTrackBack URL for this entry: Listed below are links to weblogs that reference British Medical Journal Attacks HonestReporting: CommentsI thought your reaction to the Amnesty International criticism was hilarious. I recall Harold Wilson withholding Centurion tank spares from Israel and claiming that he was doing it in their interests. It turned out that he was right. They went on to develop their own first class battle tank. While I am constantly defending Israel from the determinedly blinkered, I have to say that I believe the Israeli government should employ a carrot and stick strategy. Not just the stick. Furthermore, it is the carrots that she be publicised by HR and others not just be forever on the defensive. as a mwmber of the bri So its ok to place blame on Honest Reporting because of emails?? I disagree!Honest Reporting is so necessary. There is so much misinformation in the media because they dont FACT CHECK! Gentlemen: BMJ and other kind of media is not only falsely , abusely propaganded inciting , hatred , information , is also the contributors as AI to the terror around the world. keep doing your excellent work. the adversaries / enemies of Israel are obviously perturbed by your continuous clear and concise analysis keep doing your excellent work. the adversaries / enemies of Israel are obviously perturbed by your continuous clear and concise analysis The 22 arab countries that are against each other, but united against Israel, have been unable to destroy Israel through economic embargos or military means and now they have a new weapon, the United Nations. And sadly they may destroy Israel by using this debating society to swing world opinion. Their motto of multiply and seperate has enabled them to have so many small countries each which gets a representative in the UN. Again by numbers they can effectively sway the votes against Israel. when will the world wake up and see how the UN is strangling Israel? How could challenging the veracity, or otherwise of the facts of any given event in Israel by Honest Reporting, be stifling the truth? If the BMJ HAD PROOF THAT HONEST REPORTING WAS PRESENTING FALSE INFORMATION , HERE WOULD BE THEIR OPPORTUNITY TO PUBLICISE SUCH A CLAIM , WITH ALL THE VERIFIABLE FACTS!! It would appear that they are unable to do so ,hence the illogical comment that it is Honest Reporting that is at fault.Why not rather commend the painstaking research of those dedicated people ,who are prepared to struggle till the truth is presented in an open way for all to see It's like the 20's and 30's in Hungary during which no areas of public discourse could be conducted without the (negative) mentioning of the Joos... Why does the BMJ feel the need to publish political articles? I think Amnesty International should step back and realize that Israel is a tiny country and fighting for her very existence, for them to say that she should be abolished is ridiculous. I have lived there and I see them struggle and try to be peaceful. They insult Israel and should apologize, shame on them, I never give money to them for this very reason. Same with Doctors without Borders and ACLU. Thank you I long ago gave up on Amnesty Int'l because of their long-standing anti-Israel views. I told them so, but they were not interested. The "halo effect" is a real problem, however. Honest Reporting, you have just received a badge of honor (or honour, Brits spelling). The mere fact that you are criticized indicates that you are a thorn in their throat. Keep up your good work. Gentlemen: By coincidence I picked up a book by Karl Sabbbagh this morning at the library: Palestine a Personal History. Seems Mr. Sabbagh has a personal interest in presenting a particular point of view that he should be advertising, though as to the details of that point of view I have no comment until I have read the book. The Sabbagh family/clan (he is English on his mother's side) seems to have a history in the region including areas of Israel, Jordan and Lebanon. I used to be a strong supporter of Amnesty International (not in $$ terms), but some years ago they fell out of favor because of their anti-Israel bias (from my perspective). They have not changed. As someone with a science background I am surprised and shocked that a medical journal's editors would countenance drivel one would expect from Hamas. I am not Jewish but I see a radical spiritual change of England in the last ten years. What is going on in England? Have the English People forgotten what the Holy Scriptures say about those who persecute, curse or do harm to Israel? Why so much hatred against her? i believe that this british medical journal represents the abysmal medical resaearch done by british scientists and medics compared to the many scientific discoveries, scientific successes done by jewish israeli doctors and researchers in israel. it is a case of pure jealousy of israeli accomplishments in the field of scientific research and medical technology, drug discoveries, medical and biomedical high tech inventions......none done by british researchers. the sad part is that their society benefits from much of the israeli discoveries in both high tech and medicine, drugs and pharmaceuticals. envy is a disease. let them envy. when they are up to par with israel's discoveries, you will see a drop in their medical journal demonizing israel. likewise, i believe these british indivisuals choose the "palestinian cause", which they don't even care about, to eliminate any new invention/scientific competition coming out of israel. by eliminating their competition, they hope to advance their abysmal and outdated research. poor sods! vivian green, phd. Frankly, I never heard of BMJ. Can't help wonder how a "medical journal" gets itself into the propanda business. I guess it just proves what I've heard about Great Britain; namely, that anti-Semitism is endemic to our friends,the Brits. As to lobbies and lobbying, no one surpasses the Saudis who dispense fortunes not only to try to delegitimize Israel, but also to spread Islam in its most regressive form (Salafism) from the USA to the Phillipines and everywhere in between. (For a reference, see Alan Dershowitz on YouTube.) je regrette de ne pas avoir reçu le commentaire de HR sur les articles dans le BMJ. Je trouve important d'y répondre et j'ai regardé des émissions à la BBC qui méritaient bien une avalanche de mails. Just because HonestReporting is attacked, only means it's all the more important and true. Goodness and honesty will always be attacked until the time when the world is redeemed and goodness and honesty will prevail, when there will be no more wars, hunger or sadness. May it be NOW!! Much of what the BMJ is doing is very regrettable. The BMJ, like JAMA (Journal of the American Medical Association) is a medical journal "of record". As such, its editorial functions need to be of a much higher caliber.
Next
»
|
